Can Diamond Earrings Be Made Into a Ring?

We all have jewelry we don’t use as much as we should. Sometimes, we don’t have anywhere to wear something as fancy as diamond earrings. Thankfully, there are other options to consider when you have old jewelry you no longer wear. 

You can make diamond earrings into a ring. If you want to repurpose your diamond earrings into a lovely diamond ring, it will cost you some money. A jeweler can reset your diamonds into a ring, giving you a brand-new piece for your collection. 

In this article, I’ll discuss how much it costs to make diamond earrings into a ring. I’ll also discuss how to do it and if it’s worth the conversion. Finally, I’ll provide some tips for making diamond earrings into a ring.

How Much Does To Get a Diamond Earring Made Into a Ring?

Repurposing diamonds from one piece of jewelry to another is common. If you want to make a beautiful ring out of your favorite pair of diamond earrings, you’ll easily find a jeweler to assist you.

Getting a diamond earring made into a ring will cost you anywhere from $100 and $500. The factors determining the final price depend on: 

  • The jeweler you choose
  • Your diamond’s shape
  • Your diamond’s size
  • The amount of labor required

After factoring in the cost of labor, you’ll need a place to put your diamond. If you want to create your own base piece of jewelry in which to set your diamond, you should be ready to spend anywhere from $500 to $2,000 for the custom piece. This price will vary greatly based on your chosen specifications and how you want the ring to look. 

Most jewelers have ready-to-go options for you to consider as well. These don’t cost as much as custom pieces and can save you the hassle of designing your own. Instead, these pieces are ready to be fitted with a diamond and sent to you. These pieces cost anywhere from $200 to $700, depending on your chosen material and design. 

I’ll discuss these options in more detail below: 

Cost for a Custom Ring Setting

If you want to create your own setting for your diamond, you should expect to pay anywhere from $600 to $2,500 for the ring and labor costs combined. If you want something very intricate or made of more expensive material, you may pay even more than this for the finished product. 

Cost for a Pre-Made Ring Setting

For a pre-made ring setting, you’ll only need to pay for the cost of the already-made ring and labor, making this option’s cost more straightforward. You also won’t have to go to the effort of having a ring designed. 

You can expect to pay from $300 to $1,200, including the labor and setting costs. However, this may change if you choose a cheaper or more expensive option. 

Labor Cost Variation

With labor costing anywhere from $100 to $500, it may leave you wondering why it varies so much. The main factor affecting the labor costs is the individual jeweler you choose. However, other factors can also play a role. 

For instance, a jeweler may charge you more to reset a higher-value diamond in case of damage. The cost can also vary if you have a particularly large or irregularly shaped diamond. 

Larger and more intricately shaped diamonds require more work when putting them into a ring. So, you should expect to pay a little more for labor costs if you have a ring that is more difficult to handle. 

How To Start the Resetting Process

There are various things to consider before resetting your diamond earrings into a ring. The price, of course, is a major factor when it comes to your options. However, that is not the only thing you need to consider. 

Here’s what else you should consider: 

Family Agreement

If your earrings are a family heirloom or belong to another family member, you should always check with them before making any decisions. I recommend doing this to keep everyone happy and prevent costly repairs in the future if they aren’t pleased. Getting your diamond earrings back after a reset is not easy or cheap. 

Assess Any Damage

Your local jeweler can help with this step, but it’s important to look for any issues with the diamond. If the earrings aren’t brand new, then there is a chance they may have chips or some kind of minor damage. This can affect the quality of the ring you end up with. 

Unfortunately, chips and minor damages are not always noticeable on earrings. However, they become more obvious on a ring as you and others around you regularly inspect it. So, be sure to ask the jeweler if there is any noticeable damage to the diamond before deciding to go ahead with the resetting. 

Damage to the diamond is important for how the finished product looks and how well it will withstand the resetting process. Chipped and damaged diamonds may fall apart when the jeweler attempts to move them from one setting to another. Always check for chips in the diamonds, as it may not be worth the risk of moving them. 

One and Done

This is an expensive change for your jewelry. So, you should prioritize a long-lasting reset. This means that you should choose a timeless option that you are sure to love for a long time. This will help you avoid another resetting in the future and allow possible future recipients to also enjoy the beautiful new piece. 

Remember that a lot can affect whether or not you can reset a diamond again in the future. If you intend to wear the ring often, it can easily chip over time. This means that you may be unable to change your mind and place it in a different setting. You should choose the setting for your diamond as a final choice. 

Finding the Right Jeweler

Finding the right jeweler can be challenging for some people. If you don’t already have one that you trust, you may want to shop around a bit for the best possible choice. Make sure you look at reviews whenever possible and have a conversation about the resetting before you pay or start the process. 

Some jewelers specialize in resetting diamonds; you should also factor that into your decision. You can also check with friends and family to see if they have any recommendations for a trusted jeweler to handle the resetting. Make sure you trust whoever you choose to reset your diamond into a new ring, and don’t always just go for the cheapest option. 

Is It Worth Resetting a Diamond?

Deciding whether or not it is worth resetting your diamonds into a ring is a personal choice. Many factors go into making the right decision. We already discussed the price above, but there is still more to consider before deciding to spend money on a reset. 

Below are some considerations to take into account to help you decide if it’s worth resetting your diamond: 

Diamond Value

If you didn’t buy the diamond earrings yourself, you might not know exactly what they are worth. If this is the case, you should consider having the diamond appraised or just have a local jeweler take a quick look at it. The diamond may not be of a quality worth converting into a ring, or it could be worth more than you expect. 

No matter the worth of the diamond, it is still your choice to get it placed in a ring. However, it may not be worth spending the money to move the diamond to a ring unless it’s a good-quality diamond. So, talk with a jeweler and consider the quality. 

Your Preference 

The resetting of a diamond depends highly on what you like. This is a great decision if you prefer to wear a ring over earrings. However, that may not be the case. Remember, there are other options out there besides rings. Consider that alternative if you think you would get better use from a necklace. 

With diamond earrings, you’ll have two diamonds to work with. This means that you can use one diamond in a ring and create a matching necklace, bracelet, or other jewelry pieces as well. There are so many options available to you. So, make sure you create something you will love and wear for years to come. 

Additional Diamonds

Another factor to consider before resetting a diamond is that you may need more diamonds to achieve the look you want. This can affect the cost of the resetting and create even more of a wait for the final piece. Having a ring with just one diamond in the center is not everyone’s style, and you may consider smaller diamonds and their effect on the overall cost. 

If you have earrings, there is another diamond to consider as well, and you may not want to spend money on having two pieces reset. So, there are some other options to consider with your other diamond:

  • You can simply have both diamonds incorporated into the ring 
  • Holding on to the other diamond for resetting in the future 


One major downside to creating a ring out of diamond earrings is that they will not fit everyone. The great thing about diamond earrings is that they will fit anyone who you may choose to pass them down to. Rings are not as easy to fit on everyone else. So, anyone who ends up with the ring may have to pay to have it resized to fit their finger. 

With diamond earrings, a necklace, or a bracelet, you don’t have to worry about the jewelry fitting others. If you plan to eventually give this jewelry to someone else, consider a piece that may fit more easily. However, if you really want a ring, the next person to receive the piece can handle the resizing if necessary. 


Before you commit to resetting your diamond into a ring, consider trading it in. If the diamond is not the size or shape you want in a ring, you may be better off trading your diamond earrings and purchasing a brand-new ring. Of course, this may not be the best option with heirlooms from your family or jewelry with sentimental value. 

If the diamond earrings are still good-quality, then you can probably get a decent trade-in value. 

With earrings, you have two diamonds to work with. If you don’t want two diamonds on your ring and don’t know what to do with the other one, trading them for a ring of your choosing may be best for you. This will help you get the most possible value from the diamonds and get something that better fits your style. 

Tips for Making Diamond Earrings Into a Ring

Now that we covered the basics of cost and how to best prepare for resetting, let’s go over some helpful tips to help you get the most out of resetting your diamond:

  • Add a halo to make smaller diamonds look larger.
  • Make sure the jeweler encases the diamond so it stays put.
  • Consider different colored accent diamonds and bands to add your own style.
  • If you don’t have a plan for the other diamond, save it for another time.
  • Plan for the process to take weeks or even a month.
  • Choose the style you want most, even if it costs more.
  • Consult with a few different jewelers to ensure you get the best possible price and service.
  • Obtain an estimate to know how much it will cost before committing.

Final Thoughts

You can make your diamond earrings into a beautiful ring or even two. There are many things to consider before making your final decision. Most importantly, you should always check with a jeweler or even more than one that can help you out. 

An experienced jeweler will have plenty of experience with resetting diamonds. So, don’t be afraid to ask questions to ensure you get the exact ring you want. Also, remember that trading in your diamond earrings is an option.

If you found this article useful, make sure you save this pin below to your Jewelry board.

Leave a Comment