Is It Bad To Get a Brand New Engagement Ring?

Recently, my boyfriend and I were talking about getting engaged. He mentioned that he’d like to buy me a brand-new engagement ring, but I was a bit hesitant because the ring production’s affects the environment and it may not be affordable. With such issues in mind, is it a bad idea to get a new engagement ring instead of purchasing a pre-owned one?  

It’s not bad to get a new engagement ring if you want a brand new one, even if that means side-stepping a pre-owned or heirloom ring. The final decision to choose a brand new ring comes down to personal choice and lifestyle. 

In this article, I’ll explore when you should choose a brand-new engagement ring, as well as the factors to consider to help you make the right decision. I’ll also look at times when it might be more suitable for you to consider purchasing a pre-owned ring instead. 

When Should You Get a New Engagement Ring? 

There are times when choosing a brand new engagement ring is the best choice. For example, if the pre-owned ring or heirloom ring that your fiance wants to give you doesn’t match your personal style, you can consider buying a new one since it’s something that you’re likely to have for the rest of your life. 

Although you might feel a bit uncomfortable sharing your personal views on this matter with your fiance, it’s important to do so. 

An engagement ring is a highly personal jewelry item. It’s also a symbol of the love that you and your partner share, so it should be something you smile at whenever you look at it!

With the above in mind, here are a few other situations when you should consider choosing a new engagement ring: 

  • You want to be the only one who’s ever worn the ring. Some people feel uncomfortable about wearing pre-owned jewelry because it’s so personal. By getting a new ring, you don’t have to worry about the history behind the ring. Plus, maybe one day you’ll pass it down to your children, and the ring will be your legacy. 
  • You’ve found a ring you love. It could be that you’ve located your perfect engagement ring, and it happens to be new. Since you’ll wear your engagement ring forever, don’t settle for a ring that doesn’t make you completely happy. You should love your ring.
  • You’re worried about wear and tear. An older ring might not be in the best condition. For example, it could have a few scratches or dents due to being dropped many times. In contrast, having a new engagement ring means you can stay on top of its maintenance from the first day you wear it. 
  • You’re concerned about the ring color. Modern diamond rings that you purchase brand new usually have no color in their stones, but older stones tend to have warmer color tones with hints of brown or yellow in them. To some people, this could be unappealing because it makes it seem like they have a lower value or quality. 
  • You want a customized ring. It’s generally easier to make custom changes to a brand-new engagement ring than second-hand jewelry, of which customization options can be limited. Bear in mind customizing your ring might also be problematic if your engagement ring is a family heirloom. 
  • You’re worried about unethical jewelry sellers. You should always do your research before purchasing a pre-owned ring because certain sellers offer fake or unethically-sourced items. You must always ask for an authenticity certificate from the seller to be sure that you’re getting the real deal, as Upscale Living Magazine reports.  

When To Consider a Pre-Owned Engagement Ring

Although there are good reasons to consider purchasing a brand-new engagement ring, there are also times when choosing a pre-owned engagement ring can be a more suitable choice. Here are a few reasons to consider a pre-owned engagement ring: 

  • A pre-owned engagement ring can save you money. Generally, a pre-owned engagement ring will be more affordable than a new one. But bear in mind that just because a diamond is older, this doesn’t mean it will be cheaper than a new stone, so make sure you do your research.  
  • A pre-owned ring won’t depreciate as much as a new one. The rarer a ring, the more likely it will be to maintain its value over time. Rare and high-end jewelry tends to be more valuable in the long run because it’s more unique than mass-produced jewelry. Plus, there’s a chance that the ring will turn into a high-reward investment and gain value if you keep it long enough, which you probably will. 
  • A pre-owned ring is better for the environment. Producing a brand-new engagement ring costs money and uses many natural resources. The diamond mining stage is responsible for environmental problems such as soil erosion and deforestation. Therefore, purchasing a pre-owned ring can help you to be more sustainable. This is especially worth it if eco-friendliness is a big part of your lifestyle. 
  • A pre-owned ring has character. Vintage engagement rings have loads of character, plus if they’re passed down in the family, they can provide you with an interesting history or story. This isn’t always the case with modern, mass-produced new engagement rings. A pre-owned ring is further appealing if you like the idea of owning a unique piece of jewelry that no one else you know owns. 

Final Thoughts

If you want to purchase an engagement ring, whether for yourself or your partner, you will have to choose between a brand-new ring and a second-hand ring. There are some good reasons why you should consider purchasing a new ring, such as that: 

  • You don’t have to worry about wear and tear from the ring’s previous owner. 
  • You can choose a modern style that matches your personal style preferences. 
  • You can be the first person to wear the engagement ring
  • You can easily customize the ring in the future. 
  • You want a colorless diamond in your ring. 

If you found this article useful, make sure you save this pin below to your Wedding/Engagement board.

Leave a Comment